9.10.12

Of Cauvery water & a Constitutional Crisis...

The Karnataka Government's decision to stop the release of Cauvery water has raised fears of a constitutional crisis, as the stoppage of water amounts to defying the Supreme Court order.


The Karnataka government claimed to have stopped the release of Cauvery water to Tamil Nadu, after the Supreme Court deferred the hearing of the water dispute till the Cauvery River Authority (CRA) takes a call on Karnataka's plea to review its decision of releasing 9,000 cusecs to Tamil Nadu every day till Oct 15.
Chief minister Jagadish Shettar, who was in a combative mood, declared that the water flow to Tamil Nadu would be stopped.
According to reports, water release to Tamil Nadu is said to have been stopped later in the evening.
As a constitutional crisis looms large, Shettar expressed hope that the CRA, headed by prime minister Manmohan Singh, would meet immediately to modify its earlier order. The CRA is expected to meet on Oct 12.
Earlier in the day, the SC took a serious note of the troubled situation in both the states over the water crisis, saying "agitations do not serve any purpose".
Analysts feel the court was hinting at the ongoing agitation in Karnataka.
Earlier, Karnataka’s counsel Fali S Nariman urged the court to defer the hearing till Oct 28. Nariman also said that Karnataka would not be able to "release anything more". "It is physically impossible to release. There is already a surplus of 13,000 cusecs," he added.
Counsel also had reservation on the likelihood of the CRA taking any decision on Karnataka’s review petition keeping in view that the top court had passed an injunction order on Sept 28.
In order to make the CRA comfortable in disposing of the review petition, the top court passed a brief order saying, "We clarify that our Sept 28, 2012 order shall not in any way be an impediment in the chairperson (prime minister) taking a decision on the review petition before it (CRA)."

No comments: