22.12.09

The Case for smaller states






An article by Abheek Barman

The din and violence surrounding the government’s announcement that it’ll finally push to carve out the state of Telangana from Andhra Pradesh, has claimed a major victim: reason. Most arguments against carving out Telangana are emotive, charged with hysteria, coloured with political posturing. The only remotely sensible argument against creating Telangana is that it could set off an avalanche of competing demands for more new states. But even that argument, as we shall see, holds little water and can be dealt with reasonably. Let’s not kid ourselves. Over the last 60-odd years, successive governments have tinkered with state boundaries and carved out new states from older ones. The last three — Chhatisgarh, Jharkhand and Uttarkhand — were created less than 10 years ago, in November 2000. India today has 28 states, compared to 14 shortly after it became a republic. So let’s stop behaving as if this is an unprecedented calamity that we’re suddenly faced with. Folks who argue in favour of Telangana say that the region is backward, something that’s hard to refute. Districts like Nalgonda, Medak and Warangal are among the poorest in India. Glittering Hyderabad is located in Telangana, surrounded by these districts. Drive out from the city and it’ll take you less than an hour to reach some of India’s most backward areas. Yet, this is also the place where a lot of India’s mineral wealth is concentrated. Miners like the Reddy brothers from the neighbouring state of Karnataka have huge operations in Telangana. One of their mining companies is now being investigated for — this is hard to believe — changing the border between Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh to benefit their mining interests. Lots of resources, yet very few benefits coming to people on the ground: that’s what proponents of Telangana argue. As a new state, they say, the government of Telangana will have the political and administrative drive to do better for voters. Instead of trying to refute this argument logically, people in coastal Andhra and Rayalaseema, both wealthier than Telangana, are on a rampage. Burning state buses is no answer to an economic argument; it only leaves you with fewer buses. For many years, Jawaharlal Nehru refused to pay heed to any claim for statehood based on linguistic or ethnic factors. His sole criterion was economic: would a new state be better off after independence? Would it be able to support itself better than before? Though Nehru’s blindness to language or ethnicity was, well, a handicap the economic arguments he so loved are very important. And most arguments for Telangana’s statehood are economic. But are the assumptions of folks who want Telangana state realistic? Do people who live in newly carved out states do better than before? Nine years after the creation of Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand and Uttarakhand, there’s some reason to believe that, indeed, they do. Among all the newly created states, Uttarkhand is probably an anomaly; it wanted to peel off from Uttar Pradesh because it felt that its parent was more backward than it was. So, it’s probably no surprise to know that by 2006-07, the average person in the hill state made Rs 27,800, nearly double the Rs 14,663 made by the average UP-wallah. Most of the stories coming out of Jharkhand are about Naxalism and the fabulous wealth allegedly salted away by former chief minister Madhu Koda. Yet some of Koda’s prosperity seems to have rubbed off on Jharkhand, where the average person’s income two years ago was Rs 20,177 again, nearly double the average Bihari’s Rs 10,570. It’s the same story in Chhattisgarh, where the average income was nearly Rs 29,000, much more than the average Madhya Pradesh income of Rs 18,051 two years ago. People in smaller, newer states are better off than counterparts in their parent states. Another argument against splitting existing states is that the new ones are slow to mobilise their own funds from taxes or cesses and depend heavily on central handouts. Ergo, to control New Delhi’s finances, it’s better to go slow on new states. Sure, a state like Chhattisgarh might take time to get its taxation systems in place and need central handouts. But even a state like Haryana, carved out of Punjab in 1966, needs funds from New Delhi. Bengal, which has been partitioned several times, and therefore got smaller, is hardly self sufficient. Indeed many ‘established’ states like Bengal and Bihar are still so slow to collect local revenues that matching funds from New Delhi often go unused. All states, big or small, old or new have similar powers to collect revenues. Their ability to do so doesn’t depend on when they were created or their size, but by the efficiency of their administration and the buoyancy of their economies. The creation of Telangana might trigger cries to make more new states like Vidarbha and Gorkhaland, or split Uttar Pradesh into three. The best way to figure out what’s feasible, which demand merits attention and which doesn’t, is to set up a group, like the States’ Reorganisation Commission and have it thrash things out with everyone, and then take a call. Finally, the Congress party which dominates this government, needs to be internally consistent in what it stands for. As long ago as 2001, the Congress Working Committee accepted the report of one of its study teams and decided that it was in favour of creating two new states: Telangana and Vidarbha. Then, the BJPled NDA government was in power and it mattered little what the Congress thought. But in 2004 after its election victory, the common minimum programme adopted by the first UPA coalition also agreed to work towards statehood for Telangana. In the hurly burly of coalition politics, it soon forgot this promise and lost an ally, the Telangana Rashtriya Samiti (TRS) two years later. Today, instead of dithering, the government should signal clearly that it will work to create Telangana. And set up a group to examine the demands for other new states. Remember, the United Sates, with about one third our population, has 50 states, a number that’s only grown over time.

JNNURM snippets


The UPA government’s flagship programme Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission (JNNURM) may have to depend on private funds as the government may find it difficult to spare more resources. The Planning Commission has said it will be difficult to spare additional government funds for the “very successful” scheme that has run out of its initial corpus and there is a need for private money to flow in. “There is a risk that the scheme may lose its momentum for want of adequate funds. There is a need for private money to come into city development,” Planning Commission member Arun Maira said. Launched in December 2005, the scheme has generated a lot of interest from state governments, leading to the utilisation of the Rs 1,00,000 crore earmarked for seven years in the first four years of its implementation. Mr Maira pointed out that the scheme was enthusiastically received by most state governments as it also meant some additional Central funds coming their way. “It proved to be a very successful initiative. It made the country pay attention to the condition of our cities,” he said. With funds running out, the urban development ministry had sought Rs 50,000 crore more for the scheme from the Planning Commission. While a World Bank loan of $1 billion is likely to be sanctioned for the scheme, the need for funds is several times more. The Planning Commission member, who is also a management consultant earlier working with Boston Consulting Group, said there was a lot of scope for private money to come into urban infrastructure. “It (flow of private money) is already happening. The Mumbai metro is an initiative totally funded with private money,” he said. According to infrastructure consultant and chairman of Feedback Ventures, Vinayak Chatterjee, private investors will indeed be interested in investing in JNNURM provided the government creates bankable public-private partnership (PPP) projects and gets private players to bid for them. “This can work out provided users pay charges and there is a regulatory environment to enforce it,” he added. Mr Maira said that with the money from the World Bank coming in, the stress in JNNURM will now shift to soft infrastructure. “The emphasis will now be on soft infrastructure like management of local bodies, water management, transport management, water distribution, housing and land management,” he said. Around 40 projects have been completed so far under the flagship scheme. Some of the projects completed are construction of a six lane flyover on Memnagar junction at Ahmedabad, a sea water desalination plant at Minjur in Chennai and a flyover at Rajiv Gandhi Circle-Volume II in Hyderabad. Under the scheme, more than 460 projects were sanctioned in 63 mission cities with to improve the civic infrastructure and make it sustainable for the identified urban cities. Around 28 new cities may also be added to the list.

Airborne



The aviation industry is headed towards its busiest three months ever with the number of passengers jumping over 25% during October-November 2009 over the year-ago period, indicating clear revival in demand for air traffic. Airlines’ executives said that while flights to metro cities saw a surge in passenger traffic, leisure travel to destinations in Goa and Kerala came as an added bonus. As per the data available with the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA), in November an estimated 40 lakh passengers travelled compared with 30.48 lakh in the same month last year. In October 2009, too, 40 lakh passengers had travelled on airlines compared with 32 lakh passenger in the year-ago period. This has lifted the overall passenger traffic, which has been lagging since 2008. During January-November 2009, 400 lakh passengers travelled, an increase of 5.45% over same period 2008. Airline companies said the sharp pick-up in air traffic over the past two months is due to increase in both business and leisure travel, and would allow them to improve their financial performance, as fuel cost has not swung too sharply during the past one quarter.This should bring some cheer to airline operators, who have been laden with losses, as falling demand due to the economic slowdown and rise in fuel cost over the past few years cut into margins. Sanjay Aggarwal, CEO, SpiceJet, said October and November this year were even bigger than the two months in 2007 when the economy was still growing at a fast clip. Mr Aggarwal added that if fuel prices remain stable and there are no sharp swing in currency exchange rates, SpiceJet may post profits for the fiscal ending March 2010. The spokesperson for another low-cost airline GoAir said: “It seems to be the best quarter the aviation industry has witnessed in a long time. The demand for October-December has been good and we are now looking forward to the January-March quarter 2010.”

Doppler radar near Pamban

The entire east coast will soon be covered by meteorological mapping, as a state-of-the-art weather station, complete with a Doppler Weather Radar (DWR), will soon be installed close to Pamban near Rameswaram in Ramanathapuram district. Currently, DWRs are available in Kolkata, Paradeep, Visakhapatnam, Machilipatnam, Chennai and Karaikal. “Continuous monitoring of weather is now possible at Ramanathapuram,” said YEA Raj, deputy director general, Regional Meteorological Centre (RMC), Chennai. Last week, the department formally took over eight acres at Pamban from the state government at a nominal price. The 24-hour DWR will provide a near accurate picture of impending rainfall and cyclones. The mechanism of a radar is basic science. Radars (Radio Deduction and ranging) emit radio signals, which are transmitted to the atmosphere. Rain-bearing clouds are either ice or water particles, and when the radio signals encounter them, they are reflected back to the station.Unlike in the past when analog radars could track rain-bearing clouds only three times a day, and data crunching was a laborious exercise requiring shutting down of the radar, the new DWR will work uninterrupted, provide there is continuous power supply. “The data will be uploaded every 10 minutes and users anywhere can log on to the website for current information,” said S B Thampi, director, DWR, Chennai. The upgraded technology will help in dissemination of crucial information to farmers and fishermen in the locality. Ramanathapuram receives 85 cm of rainfall annually, while Pamban, where the DWR will be located, receives nearly 100 cm. The DWR will continuously monitor the cloud formation on land and over the sea area within a 100-km radius, since rain-bearing north-east monsoon clouds are visible at a three to four kilometre distance in the atmosphere. South-west monsoon cloud formation can be tracked by the DWR even at a six km distance, while cyclonic clouds can be tracked even at a 15 km distance in the atmosphere, said Raj. The new DWR and office complex will replace the existing weather station at Pamban which is nearly 100 years old. Work on the 30-metre (100 feet) tall office will commence soon and the radar will be mounted atop the building. The radar has a 10-metre diameter and weighs 10 tonnes along with the antenna. Located 15 km north and west of Ramanathapuram at Pullangudi village, the station also hopes to introduce wind profilers at a later stage. “Within two years, the station will become functional,” said Raj about the Rs 20 crore project.

3G auction update


The government said that the auction for 3G mobile spectrum would commence as per schedule from January 14 next year and allotment would be made to four private players simultaneously by August. "The Empowered Group of Ministers (eGoM) has decided to auction 3G spectrum for four slots as per original schedule," telecom minister A Raja said after an hour-long meeting of the eGoM headed by FM Pranab Mukherjee. Asked whether the defence ministry would vacate the required spectrum, the minister said, "There is a consensus in eGoM on vacation of spectrum and it would be alloted simultaneously to all four winners by August 2010." The government is estimating to generate Rs 25,000 crore from sale of 3G spectrum, allowing five operators, including state-run BSNL/MTNL which have already been given airwaves. Earlier the Department of Telecom (DoT) had expressed concern over delay in vacation of spectrum by the defence ministry and had suggested, in its note for eGoM meeting, that only three slots should be auctioned. The government has fixed a reserve price of Rs 3,500 crore for 3G spectrum and Rs 1,750 crore for the Wimax (wireless broadband) services. Raja said that it has been decided to allot spectrum simultaneously in August, 2010, to all the winners in order to maintain a level-playing field.

Somewhere in Jammu....


A man rides a camel, loaded with fodder.

Global Restrictions on Religion

For India, international recognition of its free and pluralistic society has always been hard to come by and while things are changing, they are clearly changing slowly. A study carried out by Washington-based Pew Research Centre, the highly respected US thinktank, India is next only to Iraq when it comes to social hostility and religious discrimination perpetrated by individuals and groups. The study titled ‘Global Restrictions on Religion’ took into account the situation in as many as 198 countries, North Korea being the only notable exception, to derive the conclusion. India was just below Iraq and well above countries like Saudi Arabia and Afghanistan when it came to social hostility in the country. Pakistan is at the third place right below India. The study, which claims to cover 99.5% of the world population, deals with restrictions imposed on religion not just by social groups and individuals but also by the government. Even in the case of government induced restrictions, India fares badly with its position in the top 40 countries out of the 198 mentioned. Even though the report says that “the highest overall levels of restrictions are found in countries such as Saudi Arabia, Pakistan and Iran, where both the government and society at large impose numerous limits on religious beliefs and practices’’ India is ranked well above them in the social hostility index. While India has fared badly on both, China has done remarkably well when it comes to social hostility even though it has done badly in the government imposed restrictions section. “Vietnam and China, for instance, have high government restrictions on religion but are in the moderate or low range when it comes to social hostilities. Nigeria and Bangladesh follow the opposite pattern: high in social hostilities but moderate in terms of government actions,’’ it says. The report clubs India with Sri Lanka, Ethiopia and Bangladesh as countries where large segments of the population want to protect the special place of one particular religion. This is how it explains the high social hostility index for these countries. “Many of the restrictions imposed in these countries are driven by groups pressing for the enshrinement of their interpretation of the majority faith, including through Shariah law in Muslim societies and Hindutva movement in India that seeks to define India as a Hindu nation,’’ says the report. In preparing this study, the Pew Forum devised a battery of measures, phrased as questions, to gauge the levels of government and social restrictions on religion in each country.