3.2.19

RK Shukla named new CBI director

The National Democratic Alliance government named Rishi Kumar Shukla as the new chief of the Central Bureau of Investigation, just three days after he was removed as Madhya Pradesh police chief by the state’s new Congress administration, in an appointment that is likely to ratchet up political friction ahead of general elections.

Shukla, a Madhya Pradesh cadre Indian Police Service officer of the 1983 batch, will occupy the hot seat at a time when the agency has been left badly bruised by an internecine feud between his predecessor Alok Verma and his deputy Rakesh Asthana.

A selection committee — comprising the Prime Minister, the Chief Justice of India and the leader of the largest opposition party in the Lok Sabha — chooses the CBI chief. Prime Minister Narendra Modi and CJI Ranjan Gogoi approved the appointment of Shukla while Congress leader in the Lok Sabha Mallikarjun Kharge dissented.

In an indication that Shukla’s appointment could prove to be a political hot potato, Kharge, who attended two selection committee meetings that were inconclusive, shot off a letter of dissent to Prime Minister Modi, saying experience in probing corruption cases should have been taken into account as well in making the appointment.

Kharge cited a Supreme Court judgment and the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act that listed seniority, integrity and experience in investigating corruption cases as prerequisites for the job of CBI director. The selection committee shortlisted the candidates on the basis of seniority, the annual confidential report and total experience in investigation and corruption probes of 100 months or more. He claimed that Shukla had no experience in anti-corruption cases. “It is important to restore the image and integrity of the CBI as a premier institution that is fighting against corruption. Hence, prior experience of having served in the institution should be given primacy after having shortlisted candidates based on their seniority and their ACR,” he said. “One cannot stand by and accept the dilution of norms when an appointment to such a critical post is being made,” Kharge added in his dissent note.

In terms of overall investigative experience, Shukla notched up 117 months, lower than the 170 months of Rajiv Rai Bhatnagar, who also spent 25 months handling corruption cases.

Kharge put former Uttar Pradesh police chief S Javeed Ahmad as his number 1 choice for the top job in the CBI because he had 303 months of experience in handling corruption cases, followed by Central Reserve Police Force chief RR Bhatnagar, and National Security Guard chief Sudeep Lakhtakia.

The CBI is still under the cloud of the bitter internecine feud between Verma and Asthana, who accused each other of corruption. On October 23, the government divested both men of their duties and sent them on leave. The Supreme Court on January 10 reinstated Verma and left it to the selection panel to decide whether he should continue in the post. The panel, in a 2-1 decision, removed him from the CBI’s helm and posted him as director general, fire services, civil defence and home guards to serve out the 20 days before his retirement. Verma declined to occupy the post, noting that he had already reached retirement age, and requested that he be deemed to have retired.

Even at the time of Verma’s appointment as CBI chief in 2017, Kharge had dissented. He was in favour of another IPS officer, RK Dutta, who was removed from the post of CBI special director just prior to the process of appointing a new director. Dutta’s removal led to the appointment of then additional director Asthana as acting chief of the agency in December 2016 when Anil Sinha retired as the CBI chief.

Shukla had been the chief of Madhya Pradesh police from June 2016 until the newly elected Kamal Nath government of the Congress party named him chairman of the MP Police Housing Corporation, considered a shunting post.

New e-tail rules hurt Amazon, Walmart market cap

Amazon and Walmart, which owns 77% stake in India’s largest online retailer Flipkart, together lost over $50 billion in the value of their shares on Friday, the same day the Indian government’s revised e-commerce policy came into effect - and at least a part of the loss is being ascribed to the new rules.

Both companies have made big bets to drive global growth from the Indian retail market - with Amazon committing $5 billion here while Walmart spent $16 billion last year to buy a controlling stake in Flipkart — as they missed out on the China market.

The new policy puts a series of curbs on how both Amazon India and Flipkart operate— restricting discounts, no ownership in sellers on the marketplace platform and disallowing exclusive product launches — forcing them to restructure operations and take a hit on sales.

Nasdaq-listed Amazon’s stock fell 5.4%, losing $45 bn in market capitalization while Walmart’s dipped by over 2% on NYSE, losing $5.7 bn. At close of trade on Friday in the US, Amazon was valued at $795 billion, and Walmart at $273 billion.

Part of the reason for the fall in the share price of Amazon, which also reported its fourth-quarter results on Thursday, was on account of the company’s plans to increase spending not related to India and weaker guidance. Also, its international sales, which includes the India business, saw a slower growth even before the new policy came into effect. Amazon’s International net sales grew by 15% compared to 29% in the year-ago period. Walmart is expected to declare its quarterly results later this month.

The department of industrial policy and promotion said on Thursday that it would not extend the timeline for implementing the updated e-commerce policy, which was released late December and caught the industry by surprise. Amazon and Flipkart, which account for about 75-80% of online retail business in India and rely on a handful of large sellers for a majority of sales, had intensely lobbied for an extension — Amazon for four months and Flipkart for six — to comply with the new rules.

Under the changed policy, e- tailers cannot hold a stake in entities that sell on their marketplace, causing Amazon India to delist lakhs of products overnight. Before the regulation, Amazon India had two seller entities — Cloudtail (a joint venture with Narayana Murthy’s investment firm Catamaran) and Appario Retail (a joint venture with Ashok Patni family office) — which accounted for a majority of the sales on the platform. Amazon may have to sell its shareholding in these two entities.

E-commerce firms also need to check they are not sourcing over 25% of a seller’s gross sale through wholesale units like Flipkart India Private Limited and Amazon Wholesale. The impact of this is likely to be felt in a few weeks as sellers start running out of inventory even as both Flipkart and Amazon India restructure agreements with brands, especially exclusive launches. Further, e-tailers cannot directly or indirectly influence the pricing of products on their platforms.

A Barclays analyst note earlier in the week stated the growth of Amazon India could fall from 40% to 0%.

2.2.19

India Manufacturing Purchasing Managers’ Index increases to 53.9: January 2019

The country’s manufacturing sector activity edged higher in January as companies continued to scale up production and employment, driven by the fastest rise in factory orders since December 2017. The Nikkei India Manufacturing Purchasing Managers’ Index increased to 53.9 in January from 53.2 in December, indicating stronger improvement in the health of the goods producing sector.

This is the 18th consecutive month that the manufacturing PMI remained above the 50-point mark. In PMI parlance, a point above 50 means expansion, while a score below that denotes contraction.

According to the survey, the increase in factory orders was the strongest seen in 13 months. Besides favourable economic conditions, strengthening demand and sales growth also picked up in January. On the employment front, Indian manufacturing firms added more staff owing to marked growth of new work orders. “Jobs increased for the 10th straight month, albeit only slightly,” it noted. The survey noted that inflationary pressures were negligible. 

Somewhere in Jammu & Kashmir....


An Election Budget


Standing in for an ailing Arun Jaitley, finance minister Piyush Goyal presented the interim Budget that was a thinly-disguised ‘election-year’ offering to the country, with every segment of the NDA’s prospective votebank being served – generously, and in some cases boldly – with sops. The Budget had benefits for middle and lower income group families; farmers and labourers; the salaried and the senior; women and children; the Armed forces; MSMEs and everyone else the NDA may count on to bring it back to power in May.

The biggest largesse, too, came as no surprise, with a doubling of the Income tax exemption limit for salaried employees to Rs.5 lakh; the announcement of an annual income support of Rs.6,000 for small farmers; and contributory pension for labourers in the unorganised sector. In his 100-minute speech, Goyal also announced raising the Standard Deduction for the salaried class and pensioners from Rs.40,000 to Rs.50,000 and proposed exemption from tax on notional rent on second self-occupied homes. In a big relief to pensioners and senior citizens, he also raised the threshold for TDS on interest received on bank deposits from Rs.10,000 to Rs.40,000, and TDS on rent from Rs.180,000 to Rs.240,000.

The tax giveaways involve a revenue sacrifice of Rs.23,100 crore a year benefiting more than three crore salary earners and pensioners -- Rs.18,400 crore on account of raised exemption limits and other changes and Rs.4,700 crore on account of raising the standard deduction.

Following BJP’s defeat in the Hindi heartland states in December on perceived stress in agriculture and informal sectors, the Budget came out with a direct income support of Rs.6,000 per annum for small farmers with a land-holding size of up to two hectares, which would be transferred directly into their bank accounts. The scheme, which would be funded completely by the Centre, will allegedly benefit 12 crore farmer families, Goyal said, amid cheers from the ruling benches. For the demonetisation-hit unorganised sector, Goyal announced a pension scheme providing for Rs.3,000 per month to workers on attaining 60 years – a move, he said, would benefit some 10 crore members of the unorganised labour force.

India to become $5 trillion economy in next 5 years; aim of hitting $10-trillion mark in 8 years

Fiscal deficit pegged at 3.4% of GDP for 2019-20; target of 3% to be achieved by 2020-21 Total expenditure to rise by 13% to Rs.27.84 lakh crore in FY20

Taxpayers with annual income up to Rs 5 lakh to get full tax rebate

Those with gross income up to Rs 6.5 lakh will not need to pay tax if they make investments

Within 2 years, tax assessment will be done electronically.

I-T returns to be processed in 24 hours

Custom duty on 36 capital goods abolished

Standard tax deduction for salaried persons up from Rs.40,000 to Rs.50,000

TDS threshold on rental income raised from Rs.1.8 lakh to Rs.2.4 lakh

Tax exemption period on notional rent on unsold inventories extended to 2 years from 1 year

Tax-free gratuity limit raised from Rs.10 lakh to Rs.20 lakh

TDS threshold raised from Rs.10,000 to Rs.40,000 on interest earned on bank/post office deposits

Tax benefits for affordable housing extended till March 31, 2020

12 crore small, marginal farmers to be provided assured yearly income of Rs.6,000 under PM-KISAN scheme. 2% interest subvention for farmers pursuing animal husbandry. 2% interest subvention for farmers affected by natural calamities and additional 3% interest subvention for timely payment. 1 lakh digital villages in next 5 years

26 weeks of maternity leave for women

Rs.3,000 per month pension for 10 crore unorganised sector workers

Defence Budget to cross Rs.3,00,000 crore

Filmmakers to get access to single window clearance for ease of shooting films

National Kamdhenu Ayog for cows. Rs 750 crore for National Gokul Mission

Capital support of Rs.64,587 crore for railways.


1.2.19

Core Growth Slows


The growth of India’s infrastructure industries slowed to an 18-month low in December, brought down by coal, crude and fertilisers.

The index of eight core industries rose 2.6% in December, the lowest since a 1% expansion recorded in June 2017. The core sector had grown 3.4% in November 2018 and 3.8% in December 2017.

The eight infrastructure sectors of coal, crude oil, natural gas, refinery products, fertilisers, steel, cement and electricity, constitute 40.27% of the total industrial production. The latest data suggest a moderation in industrial growth going ahead.

In November, industrial production growth had slowed to a 17-month low of 0.47%. The industrial production numbers for December will be released on February 12.

Core sector growth for April-December was 4.8% against 3.9% in the corresponding period of the previous year.

Coal output growth slipped to 0.9% in December from 3.7% in November, also dragging down the expansion in electricity generation to 4% from 5.1% a month before.

Production of crude oil, refinery products and fertilisers shrank in December from a year earlier, declining 4.3%, 4.8% and 2.4%, respectively. In the case of refinery products, which has the highest weight in the index, this was the first contraction in 16 months.

Steel output growth accelerated to 13.2% from 5.8% in November, while cement production was up 11.6% from 8.8%.

GDP data revised sharply


The government sharply revised the GDP growth estimates for the last two financial years, resulting in a 7.2% expansion in 2017-18 and an 8.2% acceleration in economic activity in 2016-17 — making the year of demonetisation the fastest growing fiscal since 2010-11.

The numbers for 2016-17 surprised economists as there was widespread belief that demonetisation slowed down the economy significantly. With quarterly estimates for the year unavailable, analysts were unable to get a fix on the numbers.

Another economist suggested that CSO may have over-estimated the extent of economic activity in the informal sector, which is seen to have borne the brunt of the Modi government’s decision to scrap the old Rs.500 and Rs.1,000 notes.

Government officials said the impact of demonetisation was not felt so significantly up to December, when the old currency could still be used for several transactions.

The economy took a hit in the March-quarter as well as the June-quarter, when the effect of de-stocking ahead of GST launch added to the pressure, according to government officials.

Based on the gross value added, at constant prices, the sharpest revision was seen in case of agriculture, real estate, transport, other services and construction, which some of the economists suggested did not tally with the reports post-demonetisation.

Policymakers have been ecstatic that India has maintained its position as the fastest growing major economy in the world as growth in China is expected to moderate.

Typically, GDP numbers undergo three four revisions from the time preliminary advance estimates are released. The Central Statistics Office said that the revision for 2016-17 was based on updated estimates of production and prices on the farm and industrial sector, revised spending and tax data for the Centre and the states, corporate performance numbers as well as the latest statistics on the financial sector.